It’s an unfortunate reality that
the better the effort (film or otherwise), the more significant the
otherwise insignificant flaws. I
entered the theater with high
expections—and for the most part
I was satisfied with director
Steven Spielberg’s adaptation of
H.G. Wells’ watershed sci-fi novel
“War of the Worlds.” In terms
of technical ability and craftsmanship, the film is a magnificent
achievement.
For anyone unaware of the
story’s pedigree, H. G. Wells first
penned the classic tale of Martian
domination and the impending demise of humanity in 1898.
Byron Haskin directed a 1953
film (starring Gene Barry and Ann
Robinson) that, in my opinion,
remains one of the better ’50s
sci-fi efforts. Modern updates,
such as “Independence Day” and
the campy “Mars Attacks,” are
merely variations of H.G. Wells’
original theme of “us vs. the little
green them.”
For those anticipating a rehash
of the upbeat, CGI-laden “Independence Day”—it’s not.
Spielberg portrays the alien
menace in “War of the Worlds” as
very real and very frightening, and
he channels our fear into a single
family’s plight against unstoppable
aliens.
Tom Cruise very nicely plays
Ray Ferrier, a divorced dad whose
two part-time kids, Rachel and
Robbie (Dakota Fanning and Justin Chatwin), have been little more
than distractions in his life. But a
mysterious lightning storm activates
a mechanical, tri-legged killing machine from deep underground. Ray’s
neighborhood is quickly annihilated
and Ray flees with his kids—keeping his own fears in check while
coaxing his children (who barely
seem to know him) to trust his instincts for survival.
Spielberg’s cameras rarely lose
sight of Ray: this is one man’s personal journey through an inexplicable hell. He’s not a scientist or a
fighter pilot or anyone who can
help stop the onslaught of alien
invaders. Ray’s fears are a microcosm of humanity’s—a nice
change from the superhero-type
mentality that’s been plaguing theaters lately.
I’m not sure why Spielberg
wanted Ray to be so unlikable as
the story begins, but in a crunch he’s
handy to have around. And I did like
Cruise in this role. Ray Ferrier is
scared, and Cruise’s performance
leaves no doubt about that.
For those who simply can’t
help but compare “War of the
Worlds” with “Independence
Day,” realize that you’re comparing apples and oranges. While the
latter featured a healthy dose of
humor with its ground-breaking
special effects extravaganza, “War
of the Worlds” is dark and sinister—a cat-and-mouse thriller
whose “cat” happens to be from
elsewhere, hungering for humans.
Now to the aforementioned
flaws in Spielberg’s adaptation.
For one, Ray learns that the aliens
buried their massive killing machines deep beneath the Earth’s
surface thousands of years before—meaning their intent had
been to return one day, presumably
when mankind had sufficiently
multiplied, and “harvest the crop.”
But the implication is this: the
aliens also had thousands of years
to determine the planet’s suitability for their own survival. The fact
that these creatures completely ignored any potential bacterial hazard seems to me a rather large lapse
in their logic.
Another irritation is Spielberg’s
occasional habit of attempting to
humanize his characters in the midst
of the action. At one point, Ray and
his daughter are trapped in a farmhouse basement with a shotgun-toting survivalist (a delightfully crazed
Tim Robbins). While the alien menace hovers nearby, the two men
bicker over survival tactics and
eventually clash, although the
clearly bigger threat lurks outside,
liquefying human stragglers into a
kind of alien fertilizer. Frankly, I’d
have preferred attending to the terror outside.
And the film ends too suddenly
for my taste, with perhaps a few
too many alien threads left hanging. Just what was the function of
those blood-red veins overtaking
the landscape? Were the aliens
here to stay or simply passing by?
Were we food or fodder?
Ah, well . . . mostly trivial
flaws in the grand scheme.
In a nutshell: This one’s an intense, mostly thrilling look at contact with another species (“E.T.”
it ain’t). Cruise is admirable and
Spielberg does a terrific job making life on Earth seem all-too-suddenly precarious.
It’s a pretty nifty adaptation of
the granddaddy of the alien invasion genre—well worth a look.